Photo research – how to discover the stories behind photos

Certain photographs grab our attention and stay with us, and the more we know about an image – its date, its photographer, its subject – the more compelling it becomes. This is the essence of photo research: uncovering the stories behind vintage photographs and understanding the context in which they were created.

Nowhere is that brought more powerfully to life than in Stephen Poliakoff’s riveting TV drama, Shooting the Past. It tells the story of a US property developer planning to renovate a London building containing a vast photographic archive, and how the archive’s employees try to thwart him.

Notes on the video clips

My own passion for collecting began with exactly this kind of detective work: identifying photographers, dating images, tracing magazine appearances and uncovering which films particular stills were meant to promote. With fashion photographs, the hunt often extends to models, designers and the wider cultural context.

From there it’s a small step to watching movies, reading biographies and poring over old magazines… And creating aenigma, a home for the stories behind the images in my collection.

Step 1: the print itself

The papers on which photos are printed have changed over time. This is not the place to go into detail about the subject – recognising the differences is something you can learn only from handling many photos from different periods. Suffice it to say that the second half of the 20th century and the early years of the 21st saw the introduction of:

  • Optical brighteners: these are invisible dyes that were used to make prints appear brighter in normal daylight. Their presence can be detected with an ultra-violet light. As a rough rule-of-thumb, if a print fluoresces under UV light, it’s unlikely to date from much earlier than the 1950s, by which time the use of optical brighteners had become widespread. Bear in mind, though, that the absence of chemical brighteners does not mean that a print dates from an earlier period. Lots of photos, including fakes, were made without their use from the mid-20th century onwards.
  • Resin-coated photographic paper: this facilitated faster processing, washing and drying times compared to traditional fibre-based papers. RC prints have a durable, plastic-like feel and offer a variety of finishes. The first examples date from the mid-1960s, and RC prints became widespread from the 1970s.
  • Digital prints: Associated Press’s first digital news photo was made and transmitted in 1989 at George H W Bush’s inauguration. In 1996, AP photographers used only digital cameras to cover the Super Bowl. By the end of the decade, digital cameras were sending images directly to computers, and software allowed images to be altered seamlessly, making newspaper and magazine darkrooms obsolete. Of course, analogue prints continue to be produced but these days mostly for art photos. And bear in mind that analogue photos can be digitally scanned and printed on traditional photo paper. To identify the use of digital (for capture and/or production), begin by examining the print with a magnifying glass for evidence of pixelation.

The back of a photo may be less glamorous than the image itself but for the collector it can be just as interesting. It may help to validate the print’s authenticity as a vintage piece. And it may provide invaluable information – perhaps a photographer’s credit stamp, a caption, a newspaper clipping or all three. There may be archive or library filing annotations or handwritten notes about the subject, the sitting, the date and, in some cases, clues left by agencies or newspapers that no longer exist or have since digitised their archives. Many agencies closed, merged, or changed their stamp designs in the 2010s–2020s, so these markings are increasingly useful for dating and verifying prints.

Hallowe'en in Hollywood
1941. Hallowe’en in Hollywood. More information.

The party photo here is a case in point. The label identifies the five people posing in the foreground and a couple of ink stamps indicate that the print was received/published/filed on November 16 1941 and December 16 1941. The witches’ hats and cats’ masks in the background reveal the occasion – we’re looking at a Hallowe’en party. All that’s needed are a few online searches to find out more about the five subjects (Alan Gordon was the most challenging) and what they were up to that year. And it’s fascinating!

Often it takes a bit more detective work to get to the bottom of things. Over the years, I’ve discovered a number of sources and techniques that have yielded results. Some of these are traditional, based on physical evidence; others now make use of online archives or AI-assisted tools that weren’t available when I first wrote this.

Step 2: reverse-image searches and AI-assisted research

Although these two approaches are different in theory, in practice there’s a lot of overlap. In both cases you provide the app/engine with an image (via a file or a link to an online photo):

  • Reverse image searches try to find other exact copies on the Internet by comparing pixel arrangements.
  • AI-assisted visual discovery identifies visually similar images that aren’t exact copies. It can highlight images from the same photoshoot, detect stylistic patterns, or suggest images by the same photographer.

Both approaches can help you find where an image has appeared, uncover related images and identify the photographer.

Your first port of call should be Google or Bing. I usually begin with Google Images.

Click on the Search by image icon to the far right of the search box and submit your image (file or link). You’ll be presented with a copy of the image beneath which is a series of self-explanatory tabs: AI Mode; All; Exact matches; Visual matches; About this image; Feedback.

Assuming that Google recognises your photo, a good starting point is Exact matches. Scan them and gravitate towards reliable sources such as museums, archives, auction houses, etc. Social media tend to need a lot more verification.

Next take a look at Visual matches. If you’re lucky, this may surface images of the same model and/or from the same photoshoot. Beware, though, visual matches tend to be very hit-and-miss. 

AI Mode attempts to put together a page containing the image, related images and a summary of what its research has found. Google’s AI Mode can sometimes “over-interpret” weak evidence. Treat its summary as a lead, not a conclusion, verify its sources and use other forms of research to confirm or disprove its hypothesis.

Bing Images works in a similar way. The tabs it offers once you’ve provided an image are Overview; Visual Matches; Pages with this image; Solve. 

TinEye is a third option but provides only reverse-image searches.

The good news is that, at least in the case of movie stars (less so in the case of fashion), there’s a reasonable chance you will get at least one or two matches. Then it’s a matter of going to the pages in which the matches are embedded to find out more.

The bad news is that more often than not the pages contain no useful information. The Internet is littered with images, often poor reproductions and copied from one website to another. The top “hit” is typically Pinterest, wading through which can be quite a task.

Always evaluate the source before concluding that any identification/attribution is trustworthy. One of my aims with aenigma is to provide a reliable resource for researchers and collectors, which is why I always cite date stamps, photographers, etc when I’ve been able to identify them.

The third automated option is text-based research. Any of the leading AI platforms such as ChatGPT, Claude AI and Perplexity AI offer this. All three accept uploaded images but cannot perform reverse-image search or web-scale visual matching. They’re best used for contextual research once you have leads from reverse image or AI-assisted visual searches.

Lana Turner in The Sea Chase
1955. Lana Turner, promotional portrait by Bert Six for The Sea Chase. This photo found at MPTV.

Step 3 – photo libraries

Reverse image searches miss at least one potentially important source – photo libraries. Unfortunately there’s no way (at least none that I have yet come across) of searching multiple photo libraries simultaneously, so you have to search each one separately. To make things more time-consuming, in most cases you have to search manually, ie by subject, photographer, year, etc.

Much the biggest and most important online library when it comes to researching movie stars, celebrities and events of the past is Getty Images. It is an amalgam of many photo archives acquired, digitized and consolidated since 1995 when the business was set up. Acquisitions include, for example, the Hulton Deutsch/Picture Post Library (whose purchase, I believe, was an inspiration for Shooting the Past) and the Paris Match archive.

Other photo libraries I have found useful from time to time include:

  • Image Collect – a collection of over 7 million celebrity photos.
  • MPTV – an agency founded by photographer Sid Avery and specializing in entertainment photography.
  • Camera Press – a London-based agency founded in 1947 by photographer Tom Blau.
  • The Edward Quinn Archive – Ed Quinn lived and worked on the Côte d’Azur in the 1950s, photographing the movie stars and celebrities who congregated there.
  • Iconic Images Gallery – a relatively small but growing gallery that owns the Norman Parkinson archive.
  • Magnum Photos – a photographic agency formed after World War II by Robert Capa, Henri Cartier-Bresson, George Rodger and David “Chim” Seymour.
  • Publifoto – an Italian image library with a searchable database of photos dating back to 1952.

The great thing about photo libraries is that as well as the subject they often identify the photographer and the year the photo was taken. Having said that, don’t assume that this information is correct. In my searches through Getty Images I’ve come across lots of material dated January 1 1900 – which seems to be a code for “date unknown.” Similarly, a date of January 1 of any year in most cases seems to mean that the archivist believes they know the year but not the precise date. Bear in mind also that some libraries have introduced AI-assisted auto-dating, which can occasionally produce incorrect “guesses,” so cross-check anything that looks too neat or implausible.

Marisa Pavan by Jean Howard
Vogue (UK), January 1955. I tracked down my photo of Marisa Pavan by Jean Howard to this article on “Rising stars on the screen.”

Step 4 – vintage magazines and newspapers

Vintage magazines are both fascinating and invaluable for photo research. Often photos have captions identifying the photographer, while the article they illustrate provides information about the subject. In the case of fashion magazines, you’re likely to learn the month as well as the year of the photograph, the photographer and the garments being modelled although more often than not the model isn’t named.

The archives of Vogue (US), Vogue Italia (from 1964) and Harper’s Bazaar (US) have been digitized by a company called Proquest. The archives are fully indexed and searchable. But to use them you’ll either need to have a personal subscription (deep pockets required) or to belong to an institution (such as a major library or university) with corporate membership.

I visit the British Library, which provides access to the Vogue (US) archive, and quickly discovered I could search by date, photographer, subject/model and designer (there are lots of other search options as well). For example, one of my searches was for photographs of Veruschka by Franco Rubartelli, with the results sorted by date. Clicking on a result takes me to the beginning of the article, with forward/backward arrows to navigate the pages. When I find a spread of interest, the system enables me to email the .jpgs to myself along with a transcript of the associated text. Awesome! It’s also possible to browse the magazines.

If it’s movie stars you’re interested in, the place to go is Media History Digital Library. Among other things, it has scanned vintage fan magazines including Modern Screen, Photoplay and Screenland. The runs are incomplete but still extensive and available for free – a truly magnificent resource for photo research. Scroll down the home page to access the Search facility, or browse the Hollywood Studio System collection here or the fan magazines here.

Less specific but no less fascinating is Google’s browsable Life magazine archive. It includes a search facility. Also worth a look, with subjects ranging from WWI and WWII to sports and music, fashion and the Titanic, is Old Magazine Articles, another free online resource.

Turning to newspapers, the resources available depend on two key factors: whether you are prepared to take out a subscription and what country’s papers you want to search. The two websites I’ve found most valuable are:

  • Chronicling America at the Library of Congress. It offers more than 20 million pages of digitized, full-text searchable US newspapers.
  • Trove at the National Library of Australia. It covers books, images, historic newspapers, maps, music, archives and more. Although Trove is now a subscription-supported service, it remains free for basic newspaper searches

There are lots of other free resources but most of them are pretty limited. There’s a great introduction and copious links at The Ancestor Hunt.

If you’re prepared to take out a subscription, the biggest newspaper archive is Newspapers.com. Or, if you’re interest is primarily in the UK, head for The British Newspaper Archive or The Times Archive.

Audrey Hepburn holding a gown
Audrey Hepburn holding a gown. The production code number 382 reveals that the photo was taken during the filming of Love in the Afternoon (1957). 525 is the number assigned to the individual still.

Step 5 – movie production codes

From the 1920s onwards, studios would assign a “production code” to each of their films as a way of tracking its progress through production. This helped to avoid confusion if, for example, the name of the movie or its director changed.
For anyone involved in photo research, production codes have become an invaluable tool.

During a movie’s production, the stills team would take all sorts of photos: movie stills, behind-the-scenes shots, portraits,
wardrobe tests and more. The studio’s publicity department would review the resulting contact sheets, choosing the best shots, from which they would create a “key set.” Images from the key set would be distributed to magazines and newspapers in order to promote the movie or its stars.

Crucially for collectors, each of the images in the set would be marked with the assigned production number together with an individual still number. Individual stars might also be allocated their own “production codes” for portraits not associated with a specific film.

So if you have an unidentified photo with a production code, there’s a reasonable chance you’ll be able to track it down. All you need is a list of production codes and the movies or stars with which they are associated. Fortunately, Ed and Susan Poole, the undisputed authorities on this topic and authors of Production Code Basics, have invested a huge amount of time and effort in producing just such a list (it is a work in progress). It is available in the two-volume Movie Still Identification Book Ultimate Edition available from their website store. Alternatively, you can subscribe to their research service.

In using production codes to identify photos you need to bear in mind a couple of things.

First, each studio had its own numbering system and the systems weren’t always that systematic. So in many cases the same production code has been used for multiple movies. Fortunately, it’s usually pretty straightforward to narrow down the correct match by studying the stars and figuring out a rough date.

And second, the production codes are sometimes just wrong. The guys who inscribed them on the negatives were human beings and prone to making mistakes – whether through exhaustion, carelessness or by misreading the code they were supposed to be transcribing. So watch out!

Step 6 – social media

Social media can be both a blessing and a curse for photo research. Platforms such as Pinterest, Facebook and Instagram contain an overwhelming quantity of material, much of it poorly sourced or entirely without attribution.

For research purposes, Pinterest offers too many images and too little context. The lack of reliable captions or source information makes it easy to chase dead ends, so I tend to treat it as a last resort when other avenues have dried up.

And then there’s Facebook and Instagram. Amidst the dross, there are worthwhile accounts that specialise in vintage photography, classic Hollywood, fashion history and behind-the-scenes film imagery.

. The challenge is cutting through the noise to find accounts run by knowledgeable enthusiasts or archivists—people who know their material and take the time to caption it properly.

Photo research identified the subject as Virginia Walker.
The dedication reveals that the actress is Virginia but in spite of all my efforts that was all I knew about her. Then, a second reverse image search, months after the previous one, threw up a match on eBay. The copy for sale there had been used to promote A Royal Scandal (1945) in which Virginia Walker starred as a lady in waiting to Catherine the Great. More information.

Step 7 – specialist websites and blogs

Aenigma is one of many websites and blogs created by enthusiasts to share their interests and disseminate their research. Any attempt to compile a definitive list is doomed from the outset – the landscape is constantly changing and everyone will have their own areas of interest.

So here are a few places I find myself returning to – mainly for background information, stories and insights rather than to identify specific images:

  • Glamour Girls of the Silver Screen – a website dedicated to the private lives of some of the most glamorous actresses of the 1930s, ’40s,  ’50s  and ’60s.
  • Those Obscure Objects of Desire – a blog about unknown actresses of old Hollywood.
  • Cult Sirens – a tribute to gorgeous and provocative actresses, primarily from the 1950s onwards; more pop-culture in tone, but occasionally a good source of leads.
  • Forgotten Hollywood – a blog exploring the relationship between Hollywood’s Golden Age and American history, with useful links to related websites.
  • You Must Remember This – a series of storytelling podcasts about the secret and/or forgotten histories of Hollywood’s first century.
  • Cinephilia & Beyond – a highly rated website for filmmakers and film lovers.
  • Vintage Movie Star Photos – a blog for discussing vintage photographers and celebrity subjects. It’s one of the best sources of information about Hollywood photographers of the 1930s, ’40s and ’50s.
  • The Ned Scott Archive – a meticulously assembled archive created from the estate of one of the great photographers of Hollywood’s Golden Age.

Step 8 – eBay

There’s an ever-changing wealth of material available on eBay, and particularly on ebay.com. Most of the photos are later prints and many sellers don’t provide much or even any information about what’s on the back of the print they’re selling. But some do; and if you find those sellers and watch their auctions, you will learn a lot over time and may even spot some images you want to bid on!

Photo research – what about you?

I’ll update this article as I discover new resources, and I’d love to hear from you if you have any suggestions I could add. So please do contact me with your ideas.